Right now Marley's happy with a nightcrawler cut up every other day, but I'm not sure when to start her on pinkie mice or pinkie parts (cutting them out kind of freaks me out just a little....)

I don't have much experience feeding mice to reptiles, but I do know that frozen is the way to go from what my snake friends say (They have boas and pythons), less parasites and less chance of it hurting the snake which could turn it away from wanting to eat mice.